
New York Fed President John C. Williams and staff recently visited Buffalo and Jamestown to hear from local leaders about the economic environment in Western New York.
With nearly 1.2 million residents, Buffalo is the largest metropolitan area in New York State outside of the New York City area. The city is still struggling to recover from a period of deindustrialization that began around 1981. While the local economy is more balanced now than when it was largely reliant on manufacturing, it remains weaker than its heyday. Still, leaders see room for growth. With its freshwater access and temperate summers, they say Buffalo could become a climate haven. The “Be in Buffalo” economic development campaign includes a web pitch headlined, “How Buffalo’s Weather Is Going from Punchline to Lifeline.”
For now, Buffalo remains under significant fiscal stress. For decades, city leaders passed budgets that closed shortfalls by depleting reserve funds and booking one-time revenues. A new mayor is trying to close the gap through steep property tax increases, the sale of city-owned assets like parking garages, anticipated casino revenues, and short-term aid from the state. Like other cities in the state, Buffalo remains heavily reliant on state aid.
Jamestown, about a 90-minute drive southwest of Buffalo, is in largely rural Chautauqua County. Employment in the county has declined about 20% over the past 25 years, according to New York Fed researchers. Since 2010, both Chautauqua County and Jamestown have lost about 8% of their populations, although local leaders said some residents who had moved away are starting to return.
Building New Housing; Rethinking Downtown
Buffalo’s economy is relatively diversified, led by the healthcare, education, government, business services, manufacturing, and trade and transportation sectors. While healthcare has carried employment growth in Buffalo for years, that engine is slowing. A federal cut to Medicaid state subsidies has led to layoffs and service closures at local health systems, and Medicaid work requirements taking effect in 2027 are expected to add further strains.
Other challenges include a shrinking labor pool and a persistent divide between poorer areas in the city and wealthier surrounding suburbs, local leaders say. Visitors from Canada have declined about 25% since 2025, hitting cultural institutions, shopping centers, bars, and restaurants especially hard.
Despite the economic headwinds, low housing inventory and strong demand have pushed up home prices. The median sales price has risen over 60% in the Buffalo metro area since 2020, with rents rising faster than the nation, according to New York Fed researchers.
The 7,000 city-owned vacant lots might seem like a place to build, but high interest rates and the obstacles to remediating the sites, many of which are brownfields, mean there’s little interest from housing developers, local leaders say.
On the positive side, the city released a strategic plan in 2023, something it had long lacked. Residents told officials that that the city should focus on housing affordability and housing quality, economic development and job creation, and improved public safety.
City officials are trying to make the downtown area, which is still struggling with a daytime decline in foot traffic due to remote work and rising office vacancies, into a place where people live and play. A revitalization plan including three public squares and five buildings once used as warehouses or factories would create 1,000 residential units within the next three years. More population density would support amenities like grocery stores and pharmacies, which the city lacks, officials say.
The city is working on other small changes that are expected to make Buffalo more vibrant, such as hosting more frequent micro-events, such as food festivals, pickleball tournaments, and local running races.
Additionally, local leaders expect Highmark Stadium, the newly constructed home of the Buffalo Bills in nearby Orchard Park, to have about $385 million in annual economic impact. Another bright spot is the University at Buffalo, which has seen growth in enrollment, including many first-generation college students. New leadership at UB and other higher education institutions presents an opportunity for better alignment between academic programs and the local economy, local leaders say.
Finally, local officials point to the city’s scrappy spirit as an underpinning for a startup culture. The University at Buffalo’s Center for Entrepreneurial Leadership runs a program that puts small businesses in cohorts where owners help each other. Businesses in the program, which launched in 2004, have an 89.9% survival rate, program leaders say. By contrast, the national five-year survival rate for small businesses from 1994 to 2021 from was 49.2%, according to the Small Business Administration.
Jamestown: A Focus on Job Skills
Jamestown is the largest city in Chautauqua County, which is characterized by its abundant natural resources and strong sense of community. However, the county continues to address workforce and economic challenges, with employment approximately 5.5% below pre-pandemic levels.
Due to an aging population and outmigration of many working-age people, private employers and local government leaders say it’s difficult to hire for open positions, including municipal workers, engineers, and attorneys. People who move to the area find a tough housing market: Chautauqua County home prices have increased more than 70% since 2020. Half the housing stock is rentals, and, as in Buffalo, rent increases have outpaced the national average. A shortage of Community Reinvestment Act funders makes new home construction projects hard to finance, community leaders say.
The area’s affordability problems are compounded by high utility costs and a lack of childcare services. The absence of any public transit system is also a challenge for working families. Workers’ reliance on cars leaves those with poor credit susceptible to predatory lenders and expensive loans, community leaders say.
Business leaders say many younger workers lack soft skills, including interpersonal and conflict-resolution skills, and that workers on their first job or in households struggling financially need layers of support to stay employed. To help address these problems, the Resource Center, a Jamestown nonprofit, launched a program called Supporting and Facilitating Employee Retention (SAFER) to provide case management and emergency funds for essential needs like car repairs or utility bills to reduce absenteeism and prevent job loss.
The Cummins Jamestown Engine Plant, which employees about 3% of workers in the area, has also launched a program that begins in middle school, giving children the opportunity to see how a factory works, hold tools, and examine a finished product. Other bright spots include an increase in new startups, advances on local broadband access, and the National Comedy Center —a museum dedicated to the history and development of comedy in the United States. The center, which opened in 2018, is expected to generate $23 million in annual economic impact for the region.
President Williams’s next regional visit will take place on Monday, November 23, when he meets with leaders in the Bronx.
Shawn Phillips is the head of external engagement in the Communications and Outreach Group at the New York Fed. She is responsible for broadening and deepening relationships with civic, business, academic, and other stakeholders within the Federal Reserve’s Second District.
Ellen Simon is a corporate communications specialist in the Communications and Outreach Group at the New York Fed.
The views expressed in this article are those of the contributing authors and do not necessarily reflect the position of the New York Fed or the Federal Reserve System.